After twelve hours of deliberation, a jury in Lewis and Clark County, Montana recently sided with the parents of former Miles City American Legion baseball pitcher Brandon Patch, who died after being struck in the temple by a batted ball in a 2003 baseball game against the Helena Senators. Hillerich & Bradsby Co., an aluminum bat manufacturer best known for their Louisville Slugger bats, was found liable for Patch’s death because it failed to provide adequate warning as to the dangers of the bat used by a Helena Senators batter. Hillerich & Bradsby Co.’s attorneys argued any other bat would not have hit the ball any differently; in fact, they claimed most bats on the market would have stuck the ball even harder and that Patch’s death was a tragic accident. The Patch family’s attorneys, however, argued Brandon only had 378 milliseconds to respond to the batted ball, whereas most bats on average give 400 milliseconds to respond. The bat manufacturer was ordered to pay $792,000 to Patch’s estate. The funds were allocated to cover the earnings Patch would have made had he lived, and the pain he suffered for four hours after the injury before ultimately dying. Another $58,000 was awarded to Patch’s parents for funeral expenses and their mental grief.
Aluminum bats have faced a lot of scrutiny due to their internal wall structure and because their weight is more evenly distributed than wooden ones, making them easier to swing harder and faster. A third decision made in the suit was that the bat was not defective, therefore making it more dangerous like the Patch family attorneys claimed. The Patch family said the suit was never about the money but was to get adequate warning about the dangers of these bats so something like this will not happen again. They have also started to advocate for the use of wooden bats. Brandon Patch’s baseball team reverted to wooden bats after his death.
Have an opinion about this post? Please consider leaving a comment or subscribing to the feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.
Money chasing scum. Of course it is about the money. Liars. Who is more worthless to society these greedy parents, or the stupid jury.
This has to be a joke. A 22 millisecond difference in arrival time of a baseball is worth 3/4 of a million dollars? How much does the ambulance chaser make for pushing this travesty? It is a sad event that the young person was killed but that occurs in sports or many other activites. I wouldn't trust that jury at a pie contest.
I'm pretty sure he couldn't even have ducked in 220 milliseconds, let alone 22. Epic fail for sanity, nice win for the ambulance-chasers. If aluminum bats are so dangerous, why did the league and team allow them?
Mr. Clear Thinker,Thank you for your thoughtful and insightful comments. I suspect the parents of a lost child may feel differently, but I understand that there are those out there that feel differently. Also, there are many that believe that corporate interests, and those with large amounts of money, should be protected at all costs. Greg Webb
Mr. Alphamale11:Presumably, this jury out West, in a normally conservative area, heard compelling testimony about these bats, and perhaps even expert testimony about human reaction times. They heard facts that are not revealed in the articles, and they made the best decision they could under the law. Further, with regard to juries, we trust them, in most states, to sentence criminal defendants to death sentences, so I do not see why a jury cannot decide cases about civil damages. Greg Webb
This is, of course, a tragedy for the family but this verdict is terrible. Failure to warn?Failure to warn who? The pitcher? The batter? The league? And what would a warning have done? How could the failure to "warn", without proof that someone would have listened to the "warning" have prevented the pitcher's death.I can't believe this verdict will be upheld on appeal. Again, a huge tragedy for this family but I just don't see how a label would have made a difference...short of the league outright banning the bats...and even then....miliseconds???
Sad story, really shocking verdict. I used to play softball and I have been hit with bats and balls and everything else. I wonder how far assumption of risk went in this trial. This case should not have gone to trial. It is tragic to say the least but I agree that a message on the bat would not have prevented this. Phillip Morris puts warning labels on cigarettes, and they have outsold everybody. Cause and effect, pppsshhh.
Mr. Glass,Thank you for reading the story. I am speculating that the failure to warn was with regard to the players; i.e., using these bats may produce high(er)? speed, hit balls that may cause harm to players. Good questions though. Greg
Ms. Minus,Thank you for commenting. A child may not be able to assume a risk of which he is unaware. But, that being said, you pose some good questions that I suspect the court, the attorneys, and the jury had to address.Greg Webb
Keep up with the latest updates using your favorite RSS reader
Your question will be referred to an attorney near you. If your question is of a legal nature, then by submitting this form you agree you are not forming a formal attorney / client relationship. Read our full privacy policy.
Looking for an InjuryBoard attorney closer to home? Click here.
Enter your email address if you would like to receive email notifications when comments are made on this post.
Corp Reform, Not Tort Reform
Daily Progress Blogs
Overlawyered
Safety Lex
The Practice Blog
TortDeform
Find an InjuryBoard Blog in your area:
Alabama
Birmingham
Gadsden
Huntsville
Mobile
Montgomery
Alaska
Anchorage
Fairbanks
Arizona
Chandler
Phoenix
Scottsdale
Tucson
Arkansas
Bentonville
El Dorado
Jonesboro
Little Rock
Mountain Home
California
Bakersfield
Chico
Fresno
Glendale
Huntington Beach
Lancaster
Long Beach
Los Angeles
Modesto
Novato
Oakland
Orange County
Redding
Sacramento
San Diego
San Diego County
San Francisco
San Jose
San Luis Obispo
Santa Clarita
Stockton
Ventura
Colorado
Colorado Springs
Denver
Fort Collins
Grand Junction
Connecticut
Hartford
New Haven
Waterbury
District of Columbia
Metro D.C.
Washington
Florida
Central Florida
Fort Lauderdale
Ft. Myers
Gainesville, Ocala & Daytona Beach
Jacksonville
Melbourne
Miami
Orlando
Pensacola
Sarasota
Tallahassee
Tampa Bay
West Palm Beach
Georgia
Atlanta
Hawaii
Honolulu
Idaho
Boise
Illinois
Chicago
Chicago-Land
Cook County
Rockford & Moline
Springfield
Indiana
Bloomington
Indianapolis
Iowa
Council Bluffs
Davenport
Des Moines
Fort Dodge
Waterloo
Kansas
Kansas City
Topeka
Wichita
Kentucky
Bowling Green
Louisville
Paducah
Louisiana
Baton Rouge
Lafayette
New Orleans
Maine
Bangor & Augusta
Maryland
Baltimore
Massachusetts
Boston
Cape Cod
Stoughton / Canton
Michigan
Detroit
Grand Rapids
Lansing
Traverse City
Minnesota
Minneapolis
St. Cloud
Mississippi
Biloxi & Gulfport
Tupelo
Missouri
Jefferson City
St. Louis
Montana
Missoula
Nebraska
Lincoln
Omaha
Nevada
Las Vegas
Reno
New Hampshire
New Jersey
Bergen County
Cherry Hill
Jersey City
Newark
Trenton
New York
Buffalo
Long Island
New York City
Northern New York
Syracuse
North Carolina
Charlotte
Fayetteville
Greensboro
Greenville, OBX & Rocky Mount
Raleigh
Wilmington
Ohio
Akron
Cincinnati
Cleveland
Columbus
Dayton
Findlay
Sandusky
Toledo
Oklahoma
Oklahoma City
Tulsa
Oregon
Portland
Pennsylvania
Philadelphia
Rhode Island
Providence
South Carolina
Charleston
Columbia
Florence / Myrtle Beach
Greenville
Spartanburg
Tennessee
Chattanooga
Nashville
Texas
Austin
Beaumont
Brownsville
Corpus Christi
Dallas
Galveston Bay
Houston
Laredo
McAllen
North Dallas
San Antonio
Tyler
Victoria
Waco
Utah
Salt Lake City
Vermont
Virginia
Charlottesville
Fairfax, Leesburg & Loudoun
Norfolk, Portsmouth & Hampton
Northern Virginia
Richmond
Roanoke
Virginia Beach, Chesapeake & Suffolk
Everett
King County
Olympia
Seattle
Tacoma
Vancouver
West Virginia
Wisconsin
Milwaukee
Wyoming
Cheyenne